Shimano GRX Mechanical 1x & 2x Long Term Review! The best mechanical groupset for gravel?

shimano grx mechanical long term review

“Following a multi-year global market study, product testing and development process, Shimano introduce the world’s first dedicated gravel component line: SHIMANO GRX. New for the 2020 model year, the SHIMANO GRX 800 series offers 1×11 and 2×11 drivetrains – with mechanical and Di2 electronic options – that allow riders to tailor their mixed surface riding experience and Explore Beyond.” – Shimano

shimano grx mechanical long term review
L: Shimano GRX 1x (600 series levers), R: Shimano GRX 2x (800 series levers)

Spanning a review period of over nine months, I’ve been fortunate to ride and review the GRX mechanical groupset for 1x and 2x on some very nice bikes; Titici GR02, Niner RLT 9 RDO, Niner RLT 9 Alloy, Niner MCR 9 RDO, Cannondale Topstone Carbon Lefty and the steel Ritte Satyr. That’s a lot of bikes! I’ve ridden them in areas ranging from the mountains of Northern California to the hinterlands of Florida and Georgia. I’ve also ridden and reviewed the Di2 version of GRX.

Unfortunately, I cannot list individual component weights because I’ve never received GRX in build kit form, but they are available from other reputable websites.

Shimano GRX Mechanical 1x & 2x Long Term Review Video

Shimano GRX 1x & 2x Mechanical Shifting

Due to their mechanical design, these shift levers aren’t on the same level of comfort as GRX Di2, but they are comfortable nonetheless. I never wear gloves unless it is cold, the hood covers offer plenty of grip and with the pronounced hook at the front of each shift lever, there is plenty to hang on to with no fear of losing your hand off this shifter. There has never been any hand pain or discomfort, despite riding many eight hour rides, and on one occasion, a 193-mile ride, all on GRX mechanical.

shimano grx mechanical long term review

I never used to like how Shimano mechanical shifters felt, they were always too soft, it was difficult to know if the shift had engaged. Additionally, I found it easy to overshift. With GRX, you know you’re getting a shift without a harsh clunk, not much effort is involved, and overshifting isn’t an issue.

shimano grx mechanical long term review

Shimano’s shifting mechanics haven’t changed, the inner lever shifts down the cassette, one gear at a time, whilst the upshift swing of the brake lever can shift one or many gears up the cassette. Shifting the front derailleur for a 2x setup is equally simple, but to be expected, that shift will take more effort.

shimano grx mechanical long term review
The Cannondale features the 600 series 11-speed GRX shifter

The GRX mechanical levers don’t have the higher brake pivot point of GR Di2, but they still facilitate powerful braking from the hoods, and for more power, it’s even easier on the drops, which is the only way to descend, in my humble opinion. Be sure to check out my video on descending on a gravel bike, including tips from Dave Zabriskie!

shimano grx mechanical long term review

For the 1x shifter setup, the left brake lever is just that, a brake lever, but I understand there is a new version of the left brake lever available (ST-RX810-LA) to actuate a dropper seatpost. Alternatively, Shimano offers a dropper seatpost lever that is installed onto the drops, versus actuating from the left shifter. The advantage of this lever is you can run a 2x drivetrain with a dropper seatpost.

shimano dropper seatpost lever

GRX’s mechanical shifters are comfortable on mildly flared bars, which I’m not a huge fan of, but that same comfort will cross over to traditional compact drop handlebars. They don’t place your hands in a weird angle, which bodes well for long days in the saddle.

shimano grx mechanical long term review

Shimano GRX 1x & 2x Mechanical / Hydraulic Brake Feel

The overall braking experience is much improved vs Shimano’s first attempt at drop-bar shifting with the Di2 RS685 lever. As I like to call it, that vague hyperspace feeling of waiting for the brake pads to contact the rotor after you’ve depressed the brake lever. Now, the brake pads make contact much sooner. They’re impervious to bad weather, they simply work in all conditions. Shimano has heaps of experience with MTB brakes, and that technology has ported across nicely to GRX.

shimano grx mechanical long term review
Ritte Satyr with Shimano GRX 1x Mechanical

Braking with Shimano GRX Mechanical / Hydraulic

shimano grx mechanical long term review

My opinion of the GRX brake calipers remains unchanged from that of the GRX Di2 review in that I believe they are rebadged from the Ultegra line. They work with every rotor you can think of, from 140mm to 160mm, from 6-bolt to centerlock. The brand hasn’t mattered, the brakes offer powerful modulation with reliability and predictability. For best results, Shimano recommends their rotors. Either way, I’ve experienced no issues with brake fade and so on.

Mechanical Front Derailleur – If you like 1x, Turn Away Now

shimano grx mechanical long term review
Not a GRX mechanical front derailleur, but read on below

I’m not going to extoll the virtues of 2x which I much prefer, but riders have choices and this mechanical 2x drivetrain makes that choice easy. The video further above demonstrates how well these shifts are executed, which wasn’t on a Shimano GRX crankset. I’ve experienced GRX mechanical’s magical front shifting with an Easton EA90 crankset fitted with 47/32 chainrings, and the 810 series Shimano GRX crankset featuring 48/31 chainrings. Perfection in all cases. The observant types will notice, that’s a Shimano Ultegra Ultegra front derailleur. Shimano’s shifting across their entire series is that good.

Shimano GRX Mechanical Rear Derailleur (1x & 2x)

shimano grx mechanical long term review
Shimano GRX 2x RX810

Like GRX di2, there are two versions of the mechanical rear derailleur, the 1x RX812 and the 2x RX810. The RX810 has bigger pulleys and a longer cage to deal with the extra length of the chain. Both derailleurs feature a mechanical clutch. Mechanical GRX isn’t like Di2 being set and forget, you will need to tweak the derailleur once in a while with the barrel adjuster due to cable stretch, but they’ve behaved very well, slamming gears up and down the cassette with a minimum of fuss. Both derailleurs use Shimano’s shadow concept which means low profile. The derailleur keeps closer to the frame which is a big positive for gravel cycling.

shimano grx mechanical long term review
Shimano GRX 1x RX812

I’ve run the 1x and 2x derailleurs with the clutch on and off, and noticed no detrimental drivetrain drag with the clutch on. For 2x, I leave it off most of the time, but for 1x, I leave the clutch active most of the time. Because some bikes don’t have a chain guard, I prefer the extra security of the clutch. At no time have I ever thrown a chain during the nine-plus months I’ve ridden mechanical GRX.

The clutch can be adjusted, I’ve never had the need to do that, but Shimano covers that procedure in their technical documentation. If you do choose to put more tension upon the clutch, remember, this will equate to drag in the drivetrain, so adjust carefully, and always on the workstand.

Shifting Big Gears for 1x & 2x

If the 2x specific mechanical rear GRX derailleur is like the Di2 version, you can shift way beyond the max 34 tooth cog to a 40t, as I’ve proven in the video linked here.

The negative I don’t like about Shimano’s GRX 1x gearing is its lack of gearing. 11-42 is the biggest cassette recommended, whereas I think 11-46 would be a good option. I’m assuming you could get that cassette to work, but by the same token, you could run a Shimano XT rear derailleur, at least the Di2 variant (never tried mechanical XT), and solve this somewhat limiting gearing problem. I felt first hand the limitations of a 42 x 42 low gear, and a 40 x 42 low gear, when I had to walk the Titici GR02 at Grinduro, and the Specialized diverge, the Di2 1x version, in Girona, Spain during the press launch for the bike.

I can attest that the 1x version of GRX mechanical works very well with an 11-32 cassette, provided you pay attention to the b-screw.

Shimano GRX 810 Series Crankset

shimano grx di2 long term review
Shimano GRX 810 series crankset with GRX Di2

I’ve covered the 2x 810 series crankset in my GRX Di2 review, so I won’t be repeating that here, but if you noticed in my video, GRX plays nicely with Easton EA90 47/32 crankset.

shimano grx mechanical long term review

I’ve ridden GRX 1x with Shimano and Cannondale cranks sans issues, but plan your gearing wisely.

shimano grx mechanical long term review

I feel Shimano has hit another home run with the mechanical version of GRX. I still prefer GRX Di2, the 2x version, but I believe GRX mechanical is the number one choice for a mechanical groupset designed for the rigors of gravel cycling. It’s smooth, fast shifting, comfortable and parts are easy to obtain.

Thanks for reading!

Links of Interest:

Don’t forget to Like the Gravel Cyclist Facebook page, follow G.C. on Instagram and subscribe to our Youtube Channel. We are also on Twitter!

6 comments on “Shimano GRX Mechanical 1x & 2x Long Term Review! The best mechanical groupset for gravel?

  1. Excellent review. Any comments on how this would stack up against Force 1X 11 speed mechanical? I’m looking for a group set for the great divide route and want to stick with 1X mechanical. Thanks 👍🏽

    1. Zach, honestly, I am not a fan of Force 1x, the shift lever has one point of fail as it handles up and downshifts, and I found it too easy to overshift up the cassette. With that said, the rear derailleur does have good range for a bigger cassette… research your cassette options, you will need low gears for your serious undertaking! Good luck!

  2. Thank you for the great content, you helped me a lot.
    I am about to upgrade a bike with GRX 1x but still thinking to get 11-46 cassettes. Do you get the chance to know if it works fine with it?

    Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.